Music Review | Amazing premiere!
Release time:
2023-03-20
On March 12th, after the premiere of the 2023 "New Heart" music season by the Shanghai Shanghai Nine Trees Philharmonic Orchestra, there was a wave of positive reviews. A loyal musician sent a heartfelt music review with thousands of words. Let's take a look together!
Today, I attended the on-site premiere of the Nine Trees Philharmonic Orchestra at the Nine Trees Future Art Center, which was surprising. To be honest, I didn't have much expectation for this premiere before, but I just felt that as a musician, attending the premiere of a hometown theater band at my doorstep was an attitude and a support. But as soon as I arrived at the scene, I saw Mr. Chen Xieyang, a renowned domestic conductor, also come to support me, sitting in front of me. I was still frightened and thought to myself, it seems that we must not underestimate today's premiere of the Nine Trees Philharmonic Orchestra!
Today's premiere is an unexpected performance of two of Beethoven's most important "third" works written during his transition from classicism to Romanticism. In the first half of the concert, Piano concerto No. 3 in C minor was played. Although Beethoven's "Third Steel Association" is not as well-known as the "Fifth Steel Association" (the "Emperor"), it is equally remarkable as the embryonic work of heroism in his works. The conductor of the concert is Hong Yiquan, a new generation young conductor from Singapore, and the piano performer is Qin Yunyi, a beautiful post-90s pianist. To be honest, I have never heard of the works performed by these two musicians before, so I don't have a deep impression of them, but I know that they are both well-known and outstanding in their respective fields.
Director Hong Yiquan is very unique in the placement of musical instruments on the stage. He puts the bass on the leftmost side of the stage, takes apart the first and second violins, separates the left and right sides of the stage, places the cello behind the first violin, places the Viola behind the second violin, and moves the Timpani from the traditional middle last position to the rightmost waist. The horn and trumpet are not adjacent from right to left, but are placed at the left and right ends of the orchestra group respectively. This is a bit strange for the musicians who are used to watching and listening to traditional band performances and recordings. Especially when the bass bass and Timpani are playing, the sound does not come from the traditional position. At the beginning, they are really not used to it. It is like changing the position of the left and right channels when listening to music at home. This setting, especially the adjustment of placing the second violin from behind the first violin to the right side opposite the first violin on an equal footing, may be a temporary measure taken to compensate for the shortcomings of the high pitched string part and increase the auditory effect of the string part for the on-site audience. But after a slight discomfort at the beginning, I quickly adapted.
The version of Beethoven's Third Piano concerto that I prefer is the one in which Paulini plays the piano and Abbado conducts the Berlin Philharmonic. Today, after listening to Qin Yunyi's performance, I felt very different, especially in the wide board of the second movement. The playing speed was significantly slower than Polini's version, and the piano sound was full of feminine elements. In addition, the conductor was Singaporean, and the majority of the performers were Chinese. The performance of this second movement is even more beautiful and exciting in the East. The coordination between the piano lead and the band throughout the entire work is perfect, and the conductor's ability to control is also strong. Especially at the beginning, there was a very brief imbalance between the orchestral and string parts, and the volume of the orchestral was significantly higher than that of the strings. However, under the guidance of the conductor, it quickly adjusted and the conductor's ability to conduct was evident.
In the second half, Beethoven's Third "Hero" Symphony in E-flat major was played, which can better reflect the overall strength of the band. I have heard at least 10 different versions of this work, with no less than 50 times. Today's performance, apart from the slightly inadequate treble strings, overall the performance of this work is still quite impressive. Give a special praise to the band's wind music part. I feel that the band's wind music group is special, especially the chief beautiful performer who plays the Oboe. The smooth playing breath and accurate emotional grasp are convincing. Especially in the fourth movement, there is a dialogue between the Oboe and string music, which is extremely wonderful. In the scherzo movement of the third movement, the three horns also perform brilliantly, with several segments where the three horns and the band answer each other. The three horn performers work together harmoniously and act like one person, making their performance natural. Also, in the concerto section of the first half, the solo flute also performed exceptionally well, which was extremely impressive.
The coordination of the entire performance band is also commendable, and the connection between segments is relatively smooth, especially in the second half of the "Hero" symphony performance. Due to breaking free from the constraints of the main instrument, the entire work is almost completed in one go, demonstrating the conductor's skill and tuning ability. In addition, the performers of the entire band are very young, which is more like a youth band, so the feedback on conductor signals is more agile and the performance is more dynamic.
Of course, there will also be some regrets, such as in the organization of the band. These two works are very suitable for the band playing with two pipes. Except for trombone and tuba, which are not equipped (the work itself does not seem to need to be equipped), the other four Woodwind instrument (flute, Oboe, Clarinet, bassoon) and two Brass instrument (trumpet, horn) are all standard two pipe configurations (in the second half of the performance of "Hero", a horn was added and became three horn). However, in the five parts of string music, six cellos There are 4 bass basses, all of which belong to the normal configuration, but only 9 for the first violin, 8 for the second violin, and even fewer for the Viola, 6 for the second violin. Therefore, there are fewer violins and Viola in the five groups of string music. As a result, the volume of the violins and Viola is still thin sometimes, regardless of how hard they try. If three to four more pieces are added to each of the first, second, and middle notes, the volume balance between orchestral and string music will be much better. But based on the principle of having fewer violas than one flute, in the current shortage of human resources, such a configuration is already a matter of conscience, so overall, there are still no flaws to hide!
Finally, I would like to congratulate the Nine Trees Philharmonic Orchestra on their successful debut on site, and I hope that all sectors of society, especially those in Fengxian, will pay more attention to the growth of this hometown band and provide more care, care, and support within their capabilities.
Wishing the Shanghai Shanghai Nine Trees Philharmonic Orchestra a better and better performance, becoming a beautiful cultural card for South Shanghai, Fengxian New City, and Dongfang Meigu!
Author: Old Wood
March 12, 2023


